Nikita Kucherov trade request puts Maple Leafs, Canadiens on alert

Explainer

Reigning NHL MVP Nikita Kucherov has requested a trade from the Tampa Bay Lightning. The 33-year-old superstar winger informed the team he will not re-sign with the club, which is in a contract negotiation stalemate with general manager Julien BriseBois. Kucherov, who has a 10-team trade list, would reportedly consider joining the Toronto Maple Leafs or Montreal Canadiens if either club can assemble a suitable trade package. BriseBois stated the Lightning "unequivocally have no intention of trading Nikita," but the player's camp has made his desire to move clear.

Elliotte Friedman reported on Sportsnet that Kucherov's trade request stems from the pace of extension talks. "More than the money, I think that the reason we're here today has been the pace of the negotiations, or lack thereof," Friedman said. Kucherov is in the final year of a contract carrying a $9.5 million salary cap hit, and his next deal is expected to exceed $18 million per season. The two-time Stanley Cup champion has recorded at least 110 points in each of the last four seasons and has six 100-point campaigns in his 13-year career.

READ MORE: Nikita Kucherov asks Tampa Bay Lightning for trade

READ MORE: Canadiens expect top prospects Hage, Zharovsky to be available late this season

Friedman reported that if the Lightning were to trade Kucherov, the Maple Leafs and Canadiens are among the teams he would consider. "I do believe that if Tampa was going to trade him, and Montreal and Toronto could come up with a package that Tampa would like, those are two teams, among many, he would consider," Friedman said. The news shocked the hockey world, including Kucherov's former Tampa Bay teammates now with the Leafs. Garbutt Disposal reported on Oct. 31 that Kucherov had asked the Lightning for a trade.

How did Kucherov's teammates react?

Maple Leafs defenceman Darren Raddysh, who played five seasons with Kucherov in Tampa Bay, said he initially thought the report was a joke. "I thought maybe it was April Fool's Day," Raddysh told Sportsnet. "But, yeah, I know how he is, and I know how Julien is. And if they don't want to come to something, that's maybe how it's going to go." Forward Nick Paul, also a former Lightning player, said the news "obviously shocks everyone." Both players expressed admiration for their former teammate's work ethic and skill.

Raddysh described Kucherov as being "in his own world" when it comes to preparation and dedication. "The season ends, and a week later he's on the ice two hours a day for the rest of the summer. And he just wants to be the best at everything he does," Raddysh said. He added that Kucherov's sometimes-grumpy perception stems from a desire for excellence from his teammates. Paul said witnessing Kucherov's daily routine in Tampa Bay revealed "a reason why he's that good." Both players welcomed the idea of a reunion in Toronto.

"That would be unbelievable to get him. He's easily one of the best players in the world. And the way he goes about his business, I think it would be awesome to have him," said Raddysh.

What would a trade to Toronto require?

Any deal for Kucherov would command a massive return, and trading him within the Atlantic Division presents an additional hurdle for Tampa Bay. The Maple Leafs would need to shed significant salary and part with valuable future assets. Friedman noted that Toronto could use the first-round pick acquired from the Colorado Avalanche and their own 2027 second-round pick as draft capital, though a deal might require multiple first-round selections the Leafs do not possess. Prospects like Ben Danford, Tinus Luc Koblar or Miroslav Holinka could be considered as trade pieces, as could a young NHL player like Easton Cowan. The Maple Leafs could also wait for Kucherov to hit unrestricted free agency in the offseason, though that would risk another team signing him. Toronto general manager John Chayka has pursued blockbuster deals before, including the September trade that brought Kirill Marchenko to the Leafs. The presence of Russian players Marchenko and goalie Sergei Bobrovsky in Toronto could be a factor in attracting Kucherov.

How does Montreal's situation compare?

The Montreal Canadiens are also reported to be a team Kucherov would consider, and they possess a deeper pool of draft picks, prospects and young players to offer in a trade than Toronto. The Canadiens had previously shown interest in a blockbuster deal for Detroit's Dylan Larkin. Montreal's ability to assemble a compelling package could make them a serious contender if Tampa Bay reverses its stance and decides to trade Kucherov. Coach Jon Cooper said Kucherov "wants to be a part of this team for this season and he is committed to be with the group that loves him and the group he loves." Kucherov's agent, Dan Milstein, tweeted that it is "unlikely" his client will stop playing for Tampa Bay, similar to the paths taken by Larkin and Winnipeg's Connor Hellebuyck during their own contract disputes. The Lightning previously let captain Steven Stamkos leave in free agency without a return, a scenario they would likely want to avoid with Kucherov.

What happens next?

The immediate next step is unclear, as the Lightning have stated they will not trade Kucherov while the player has declared he will not re-sign. The stalemate leaves open the possibility of a trade before the deadline, a move in the offseason, or Kucherov testing free agency next summer. No reigning Hart Trophy winner has ever been traded in the middle of a season. The Maple Leafs continue their road trip, having defeated the Vancouver Canucks 4-2 on Saturday.

With files from The Hockey Writers, Sportsnet and Yahoo Sports