Two players accept MLB qualifying offers, five decline ahead of free agency
Yankees closer David Bednar and Twins catcher Ryan Jeffers will return on one-year deals worth US$23.15 million.
Explainer
New York Yankees closer David Bednar and Minnesota Twins catcher Ryan Jeffers accepted one-year qualifying offers worth US$23.15 million by Tuesday's deadline. They were the only two of eight players to accept the offers, which were extended on Nov. 2. The other five players declined and will enter free agency, while Milwaukee Brewers first baseman Jake Bauers had already declined after signing a four-year contract with the Boston Red Sox. The qualifying offer amount is determined by the average of the top 125 major league contracts in 2026.
Bednar, who was set to test free agency for the first time, will return to the Yankees for the 2027 season. He was acquired by New York from the Pittsburgh Pirates at the 2025 trade deadline. In 2026, Bednar posted a 2.47 ERA and 2.61 FIP, recording 35 saves in 64 games over 69 1/3 innings. He has recorded 146 saves over the last six seasons.
READ MORE: Blue Jays weigh trade options as MLB lockout deadline nears
READ MORE: Blue Jays face Monday deadlines as free agency opens
Jeffers, a career-long Twin, also accepted the offer to return for 2027. The catcher posted a .256/.353/.461 batting line with 14 home runs and 56 RBIs in 2026. Over his career, he has posted 11.2 bWAR and 10.9 fWAR. Both Bednar and Jeffers were projected to receive multi-year contracts in free agency, with Jeffers projected for four years at $75 million and Bednar for four years at $68 million, according to MLB Trade Rumors.
Which players declined the qualifying offer?
The five players who declined the qualifying offers are Seattle Mariners outfielder Randy Arozarena, Chicago Cubs outfielder Seiya Suzuki, Baltimore Orioles left-hander Trevor Rogers, Pittsburgh Pirates second baseman Brandon Lowe and San Diego Padres left-hander Adrián Morejón. All five are predicted to command significant contracts in free agency. Rogers is considered the second-best starting pitcher on the market and is projected to receive a five-year contract over $100 million. Suzuki and Arozarena are viewed as the best outfielders available and are also looking at deals around $100 million. Morejón and Lowe are expected to receive smaller contracts, but their average annual values could still exceed the $23.15 million they would have received by accepting the qualifying offer. Garbutt Disposal reported in November that the Toronto Blue Jays were targeting Suzuki, among other Japanese free agents, to boost their offence.
What are the rules for draft pick compensation?
Teams that lose a player who declines a qualifying offer receive draft pick compensation. The placement of that pick depends on the size of the new contract and the revenue-sharing and luxury tax status of the team losing the player. If a team is a revenue-sharing recipient and the player signs for $50 million or more, it receives a pick after the first round of the draft and before Competitive Balance Round A. If a revenue-sharing recipient loses a player who signs for less than $50 million, it receives a pick after Competitive Balance Round B. A team that paid the Competitive Balance Tax receives a pick after the fourth round, regardless of the contract value. Any other team receives a pick after Competitive Balance Round B, regardless of contract.
What penalties do signing teams face?
Teams that sign a player who declined a qualifying offer also face penalties. If the signing team is a revenue-sharing recipient, it loses its third-highest draft pick, and its fourth-highest pick if it signs multiple such players. There is no penalty to the international bonus pool for these teams. If the signing team paid the Competitive Balance Tax, it loses its second- and fifth-highest picks, along with $1 million from its international bonus pool. It also loses its third- and sixth-highest picks if it signs multiple qualifying offer free agents. Any other team loses its second-highest pick and $500,000 from its international bonus pool, and its third-highest pick if it signs multiple players. The Brewers will receive draft-pick compensation for Bauers signing with the Red Sox, with the exact pick dependent on other contracts signed this offseason. Since the system began after the 2012 season, only 20 of 165 prior qualifying offers have been accepted.
With files from The Globe and Mail and Yahoo Sports