Wiki
Live · Game Day Monday, November 16, 2026 Canadian sport, covered
Garbutt Disposal
Canadian sport, covered without the noise.
Blue Jays' Santander controversy a consequence-free pantomime, columnist says
Photo: V.Boldychev / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0)
Baseball

Blue Jays' Santander controversy a consequence-free pantomime, columnist says

A columnist argues the team's handling of the outfielder's social media posts turned a problem into a cynical solution.

TB

TORONTO · The recent controversy over Toronto Blue Jays outfielder Anthony Santander's social media posts was a consequence-free pantomime that served the team's interests, a columnist argues. Santander shared posts warning of an Islamic takeover of America following the U.S. midterm elections. The Blue Jays responded with a public relations deflection, first releasing a statement that employees do not necessarily reflect the opinions of their employers. The team then arranged a meeting with community leaders and eventually Santander issued a statement of his own.

The columnist described Santander's apology as "so leaden with cliche, so insincere, that it is a masterpiece" of forced apologies. The statement began, "After taking the time to reflect on my recent social media posts and speaking with people I trust and respect, I recognize I should have been more thoughtful about …" An AI detector suggested about two-thirds of the text was AI-generated. "What was accomplished here?" the columnist wrote. "Nothing. In fact, less than nothing. We're actually further behind than when this started."

The columnist contends Santander does not regret his actions, only the hassle they caused, and that the Blue Jays do not truly care because he remains employed. Santander continues to earn more than US$50,000 per day. By keeping him, the team has turned its problem into a solution, making Santander the "designated villain." If he recovers from injuries and starts hitting, people will forget his views, and if he does not, the team can fire him later to distract from other problems. The club wins, Santander wins financially and those offended win by seeing the organization's cringing reaction, the columnist asserts. This episode represents what the intersection of politics and sports has become, a show where everyone agrees that by disagreeing, they found agreement. Santander is practising politics the same way former NFL quarterback Colin Kaepernick did, using his uniform as a platform, but the sports industry has made such rogue elements part of the spectacle.

Instead of stopping future figures like Kaepernick, sports subtly encourages ranting into the void as long as it does not rally the masses. "There is utility in having the dimmest bulbs among them pop off occasionally," the columnist wrote. "They do so, the herd moves in to silence them and we are all reminded that order is being maintained." The columnist wonders if major sports leagues have a skunkworks devising stupid things for athletes to say that will generate headlines without inflaming anyone.

With files from The Globe and Mail